Nathan WileyNarrator (voice) Cherise SilvestriNarrator (voice) Russell BentleyNarrator (voice) Gino RaimondoDetective Ronald Flagg (uncredited) David McConnellSelf - True Crime Author Joshua PivatoSaul Dos Reis Bernadette MedhurstDianne McKnight Heath HudsonAnthony Pasquale Marta LegradyDeb Bruce (David's Sister) Val ColeMargaret 'Peg' Schobert Bryan EdwardsDetective Mark Williams Nicole FairbairnSue Taynor (Jessica's Mom) Sid McMillanDetective Scott Murphy Stacey IsemanKim Philipson John 'JR' RossDetective Greg Dunn (uncredited) Eric KutheDetective Jeff Allison Rachel Rain PackotaRazakel Chandler BoriskaMelanie Wells Linnea Currie-RobertsNichole Cable Maarika Pinkney FreundKristine Wiley (Nichole's Mom) Todd PerryDetective Smith Mandi NicholsonHarleigh Robertson Sonya ProehlSarah Mason (Kyle's Girlfriend & Bryan's Ex) Brandon WilsonBryan Butterfield Staci BouskillTeresa McBain Aveleigh KellerKacie Woody Sidney SholdiceJessica Bradford Curtis DesrosiersLt. Jim Barrett Jamie TarantiniAmanda Howard Anna-Sigga NicolazziSelf - ADA, Brooklyn, NY Halle TatorSamantha Chonski Emily FryeAshley Reynolds Maggie GarrisonElizabeth Shubert Merritt CrewsAngela Reynolds James CoburnSpecial Agent Meyer Jenna HarrisDanielle Dreher Brian McDonaldDetective Chad McDonald Kunta MurangeMichael Minor Alyssa GoodridgeJasmin Nuñez Orville CummingsAndres Ceballos Celine BaumansMelanie Nuñez Wanda CrostaDenise Suarez Mason CromwellDet. Terence Munnelly Gloria AllredSelf (archive footage) Madeleine WiedmerAutumn Pasquale Alexandera YetmanBarb DeFrance (Family Friend) Joseph JR YeboahDante Robinson Diana GoldmanLeslie Belkin Drew RiedstraMajor Campbell Veronique Auger-DroletRenee Blanchard Dylan WorthBlaine Buckles Margaret EvraireJessica Sacco Patrick McFaddenMatthew Puccio Adam MartignettiAndrew Forney John PhillipsChris Wright Richard CrossmanJack aka Richard Beasley Thomas BrouwerBrogan Rafferty Julia FloodAshley Smith / Lauren Gash Sarah Jean HodkinsonAlisa Betts Sarah Lynn StrangeJeana Booth, Amanda's Mom Jason BigioOfficer Brandon Shrout John LaughlinDetective Troy Pharr Nicole WilliamsJenn Clark (wrongly credited under Jamie Elizabeth Sampson) Samantha Wright LawrenceTheresa Bridegroom Emily MartellMikayla, Jenn's Daughter Allen CorbalanConnor, Theresa's Son Alan BeleriqueAaron Thomas, Jenn's Friend Tracy RowlandMichele Mulford, Neighbor Andrew FlemingDetective Jason Mackie Steve RankineFBI Special Agent Don Kleber Nelson PerazzaCarlos Estanquiero David C. MalcolmPastor (uncredited) Olenka DabrowskiAnastasia Solovieva King Jean-Claude PaquetIndle King Spencer GattenDaniel Larson Jodi Morneau (Eve Edwards)Detective Jamison Sergey VolkovSergei Ivanov Brian Scott CarletonProfessor Jim Aune Michael ChwastiakDetective Ohana Peter BavisBarry Hornstein Dave SokolowskiDetective Bill Law Sandra FloresKathy Hornstein Natalie Novak RemplakowskiJamie Stice Lawrene DenkersJeannie Stice Susannah KiernanKathy Coy Melissa BurdeySherri Coleman Darius ParsonsGarrett Coleman Carter GilliamGavin Coleman Shawn J. HamiltonDetective Justin Barlow Tom PollockDirector / Writer Mary DownesDirector / Writer Sean GrundyDirector / Writer Simon JacobsDirector / Writer Simon JacobsDirector / Writer Mat CatlingDirector / Writer Matthew CatlingDirector / Writer Ben MoleDirector / Writer Edmund CoulthardExecutive Producer Nick Cory-WrightExecutive Producer Lindsay ShaperoExecutive Producer Finn BuntingAssociate Producer Kate Harrison KarmanExecutive Producer Stuart BrindleArt Direction Adrian GreenlawProduction Design / Production Designer Tom PridhamDirector Of Photography Oliver SchofieldDirector Of Photography Matt BroadDirector Of Photography Shannon RuddockDirector Of Photography Neve CunninghamDirector Of Photography Chris Titus-KingDirector Of Photography Antoine BenhiniDirector Of Photography Paul LangDirector Of Photography Kev RobertsonDirector Of Photography Simon FanthorpeDirector Of Photography / Sound Rick CoxDirector Of Photography Paul KirsopDirector Of Photography David Z. LamDirector Of Photography Nate CarringtonDirector Of Photography Kevin RasmussenDirector Of Photography Stella MargaritisKey Makeup Artist Dominic WebbWardrobe Designer Katie MinnisKey Makeup Artist Dawn ThompsonWardrobe Designer Ashley WoodWardrobe Designer Lauren CowleySecond Assistant Director Anthony LefresneAssistant Director Patrick HepburnSecond Assistant Director Lee KesterbergFirst Assistant Director Mark MacDonaldAssistant Director Amanda NanfoSecond Assistant Director Barrie PeaseOnline Editor Felix GuerainArchival Footage Coordinator Tom HoweOriginal Music Composer Alexandre GougeonSound Recordist Dallas BoyesSound Recordist Rada DanilovicSound Mixer James BelyeaSound Recordist Jared TransfieldSound Recordist Stephen PerkinsSound Recordist Brendan MichieSound Recordist Gus HarrisSound Recordist Johnni JavierProduction Director Gloria MannCasting Director Debra GibsonProduction Accountant Matt MacLellanProduction Coordinator Noemí Rodriguez VidalProduction Secretary Megan TaylorProduction Manager Thomas HamiltonLine Producer Nicole TranProduction Coordinator Henrietta TaylorResearcher Regie GardenerProduction Manager Matt WatierProduction Manager Eileen AldousProduction Designer Ella ChipchaseProduction Coordinator James HankinAssistant Production Coordinator Amanda ForsgrenResearcher Stephanie PowellProduction Manager Michael MarottiUnit Production Manager Stephanie WinterProduction Coordinator Chris QuiggLocation Manager Jordan BaxterUnit Production Manager Barclay J. MaudeUnit Production Manager Charlie PanapaProduction Coordinator Francine DiBaccoAssistant Production Coordinator Vincent MoskowecProduction Designer Kate DunnProduction Coordinator Scott WoodLocation Manager Paul EvansProduction Manager Chandler CorbeilleProduction Assistant Isabella RedivoProduction Assistant Matt CassilsLocation Manager Ali LewisProduction Coordinator Phil RoseProduction Assistant Vanesa ChowProduction Assistant Donna HigginsLine Producer Tim RidingUnit Production Manager Olivia MakishProduction Designer Cindy CastelblancoProduction Assistant Kevin NguyenProduction Assistant Amir AlimirzaProduction Accountant 
