Dion GrahamSelf - Narrator Richard DysartSelf - Forensic Supervisor Trey GowdySelf - Solicitor of the 7th Judicial Court Scott CraneDetective Combs Beth DuntonSelf - Forensics, Virginia Beach Police Department Madison Renee ElsnerAshley Mike MatherSelf - Investigative Reporter, WTKR Leah BushSelf - Chief Medical Examiner, VA Caroline BurtForensic Expert Mitchell SalbergDetective Brennen Melinda BoniniDenise Corbin Lary CrewsStephanie's Father Daniel EltonSelf - Investigator, Redlands Police Department Abigail McConnellJennifer Myers Rod L HarrellCaptain Steven Nigrelli Foster WilsonCristina Moore Jason YownSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Angela B. CoreySelf - State Attorney, Florida 4th District Mark BrannenSelf - Redlands Police Department Reid LindseySelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Summer MaloneStudent Victim Kathleen KingstonSelf - Jacksonville Polce Department Alan PetersonSelf - Redlands Sewer Collections Systems Stephen DentonSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office John VindiolaSelf - Redlands Sewer Collections Systems Andrew LavenderSelf - Jacksonville Polce Department Taylor GarnerSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Eddie BoundsSelf - Jacksonville Beach Police Department Michael RamosSelf - San Bernardino Co. District Attorney Melissa NelsonSelf - Former Assistant State Attorney, Florida Randall EmonSelf - Coroner Investigator, San Bernardino Co. Faith GoodwinSelf - Rhonda's Mother-in-Law Betty M. SimonSelf - Tristan Jensen's Grandmother William CarlyleSelf - Jacksonville Beach Police Department Randy C. HardySelf - Spartanburg Public Safety Department James ChoateSelf - Jacksonville Beach Police Department Sally BellSelf - Tristan Jensen's Aunt Cathy TessierSelf - Rhonda's Mother Tim PetreeSelf - Florida Department of Law Enforcement Matthew ReiterSelf - Tristan Jensen's Cousin Joey FarrellSelf - Rhonda's Brother Paul PinkhamSelf - Reporter, Florida Time-Union Brandon ReiterSelf - Tristan Jensen's Cousin John BarronSelf - South Carolina Law Enforcement Division Aymee DudleySelf - Corey Parker's Friend Randolph BeasleySelf - Investigator, Redlands Police Department Harry HatchSelf - San Bernardino Co. Bomb Squad Ed GuthroSelf - Spartanburg Public Safety Department Laura SiegelKelly Bullwinkle Chad T. WoodOffice Rollins Douglas DemangoneSelf - Detective, York County D.A.'s Office Michael UmanskySelf - Alex's Brother Greg DavisSelf - District Attorney Walt FemlingSelf - Blaine County Sheriff's Office Michael MerrimanSelf - Investigator Gretchen Sheets-UdySelf - Kathy Sheet's Daughter Scott PeeblesSelf - Detective Madhavi MartinSelf - Oak Ridge National Laboratory Tom FitzmauriceSelf - Detective William FlynnSelf - Forensic Document Examiner Don BellSelf - Salt Lake City Police Department Carol TerrySelf - Medical Examiner Linda VavoldSelf - Diane's Sister Cyndi HallSelf - Idaho State Police Forensic Services James VavoldSelf - Diane's Brother-in-law Jill MurphySelf - Pima County Sheriff's Dept. Sylvia R. LaffertySelf - Pinal County Attorney's Office Ricky SmithSelf - Detective Brad FoustSelf - Pima County Sheriff's Dept. Jerry TaylorSelf - ATF Explosives Officer Jim J. ThomasSelf - Prosecuting Attorney Henri Grissino-MayerSelf - University of Tennessee Mark O'NeilSelf - Rachelle's Father Marcus HeadSelf - Detective Robert StottSelf - Deputy District Attorney Pam O'NeilSelf - Rachelle's Mother David WinstonSelf - Forensic Pathologist, Pima County Patti PreziosoSelf - Former New Jersey State Prosecutor Kim SmithSelf - Reporter, Arizona Daily Star Louis PerezSelf - FBI Agent Susan DewittSelf - Assistant State Attorney Ken SerranoSelf - Reporter Brent AshworthSelf - Historical Document Collector Robert DugdaleSelf - Assistant State Attorney Terri ChristensenSelf - Steven Christensen's Widow Russ HalcomeSelf - Investigator Lateef MunginSelf - Reporter Frank SheridanSelf - Medical Examiner Daphne StidhamSelf - Brian Stidham's Widow Richard PlattSelf - Pinal County Attorney's Office Mitch SelmanSelf - Collin County Sheriff's Office Stuart RobinsonSelf - Idaho State Police Kelly AndersonSelf - Pima County Sheriff's Dept. Lourdes Salomón LopezSelf - Ex-Fiancée of Bradley Schwartz Robert O'NeilSelf - Rachelle's Uncle Vivian O'NeilSelf - Rachelle's Grandmother Char ClarkSelf - Rachelle's Aunt Ross KirtleySelf - Idaho State Police Chris HoganSelf - Pima County Sheriff's Dept. Scott WardSelf - Idaho State Police Megan KennedySelf - Rachelle's Friend Jennifer DaintySelf - Convenience Store Owner Jeff BrownriggSelf - Collin County Sheriff's Office Tiara M. EllisSelf - Reporter Pierre HerdingSelf - Brian Stidham's Father-in-Law Diane StubbsSelf - Collin County Sheriff's Office Nathan CorderSelf - Idaho State Police A.P. DavidsonSelf - Texas Rangers Greg HilbigDNA Technical Leader Matthew VaughanDana Ewell M. William PhelpsSelf - Author, Murder in the Heartland Richard SchimmelpfennegDetective Mattson Christine LozanoDetective Melinda Sue GisserBobbie Jo Stinnett Michael HolbrookSelf - Pinellas County Sheriff's Office Coco SaltzgiverSelf - Karin's Sister Karolina SzamfeberJennifer Braun Catherine DodsonSelf - Senior Commonwealth's Attorney Jaccii FarrisSelf - Reporter, WFMZ-TV William FitzpatrickSelf - Onondaga Co. District Attorney Robert EganSelf - Pennsylvania State Police Suzanne L. NoffsingerSelf - Miami Valley Regional Crime Lab Chris CurticeSelf - Fresno County Sheriff's Department Chyleen FowlerSelf - Dana's Mother Kim HudelsonSelf - Linda's Daughter Darren WhiteSelf - Nodaway County Sheriff's Office James BruchakSelf - Pennsylvania State Police Jon FrankSelf - Reporter, The Virginian-Pilot Chuck WrightSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Anna CoxSelf - Pinellas County Sheriff's Office Kathryn RogersSelf - Joanna's Mother Mark WhittakerSelf - Darke County Sheriff's Office Paul YoakamSelf - Virginia Beach Police Department John SouzaSelf - Fresno County Sheriff's Department Tal EnglishSelf - Lubbock Police Department Jeffrey HammerschmidtSelf - Fresno County District Attorney's Office Rick GregorySelf - Solicitor's Office Allan WoodSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Liz RoccaSelf - Investigative Reporter, Komo News Larry NalvenSelf - Pinellas County Sheriff's Office Ross M. GardnerSelf - Crime Scene Analyst Randy StrongSelf - Maryville Police Department Rodney BakerSelf - Darke County Sheriff's Office Jim KenyonSelf - Investigative Reporter, WSTM-TV Robert BoyleSelf - Dickinson College Bill LougherySelf - Assistant State Attorney Michael PaceSelf - Witness Kelly OrmsbySelf - 1st Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, Darke Co. Joe Bill RogersSelf - Joanna's Father Dominick SpinelliSelf - Onondaga Co. Sheriff's Department Catherine MalletSelf - Karen's Friend Amber HolscherSelf - Linda's Granddaughter David Castor Jr.Self - David Castor's Son Sridhar NatarajanSelf - Lubbock County Chief Medical Examiner Thien DoSelf - King County Sheriff's Office Chris BreunigSelf - Lubbock Police Department Ben EspeySelf - Former Nodaway County Sheriff Uvah RobackSelf - Summer's Mother Tom SmithSelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Troy RawlingsSelf - Davis County Attorney Richard EwellSelf - Dale's Brother William M. MowreySelf - Pennsylvania State Police Richard HowellSelf - Prosecuting Attorney, Drake Co. Timothy DuerrSelf - Miami Valley Regional Crime Lab Lilly Smalls GallmanSelf - Forensic Scientist, SLED Hugh MurphySelf - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office Shawn TrisselSelf - Darke County Sheriff's Office Terry FranklinSelf - Forensic Scientist, Washington State Patrol Craig PetersonSelf - Sr. Deputy Prosecutor, King County Carl BomanSelf - Lisa Montgomery's Ex-Husband Tray PayneSelf - Lubbock County District Attorney's Office Antonio MenchacaSelf - Lubbock County Sheriff's Office Steven ElliottSelf - Reporter, Fresno Bee Kimberley WhiteheadSelf - Ronald's Daughter Suzanne MilesSelf - Utah Bureau of Forensic Services Mike GarskeSelf - King County Sheriff's Office David ZellisSelf - 1st Assistant District Attorney, Bucks County, PA Brad BensonSelf - Woods Cross Police Department Clarence MontgomerySelf - Woods Cross Police Department Caitlin BishipKarin Strom David CargillDirector / Writer / Co-Executive Producer Gabe TorresDirector / Producer Brian CoughlinDirector / Writer / Producer Scooter YanceyDirector / Writer / Producer Jude Gerard PrestDirector / Producer Fred PeabodyDirector / Writer / Producer Nancy GimbroneWriter / Producer Nino LopezWriter / Producer Joseph PeicottAssociate Producer Patrick SheaAssociate Producer Robert KirkExecutive Producer Rob LihaniExecutive Producer Brian RunnelsAssociate Producer Nora DonaghyAssociate Producer Sara BurnsAssociate Producer Diana SperrazzaExecutive Producer Bill TotoloCinematographer Michael A. NashCinematographer Stephen GrahamCinematographer Jeremy EvansCinematographer Tristan WhitmanCinematographer Wyatt ChannellSenior Producer: Investigation Discovery Keila WoodardAssociate Producer: Investigation Discovery Lindsey Foster BlumbergAssociate Producer: Investigation Discovery Gerald MassimeiRe-Enactment Producer 
