Sign In

THIS WEEK ONLY: 40% Off Any Plex Pass Plan

Personal media fans, this one’s for you.

Use code ANYPASS40

Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy

Samuel and Randy

Directed by Maggie Kiley
TV-MA
S1 • E3    Oct 16, 2025    58m
7.56.8
Add Show to Watchlist
The media circus begins. Amirante questions whether defending Gacy is the right choice. The Piests cope with the reality of what Gacy did to Rob. Sam Stapleton and Randy Reffett navigate boyhood in Uptown.

Where to Watch Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy - S1 • E3

Cast of Samuel and Randy

  • Michael ChernusJohn Wayne Gacy
  • Gabriel LunaDet. Rafael Tovar
  • James Badge DaleChief of Detectives Joe Kozenczak
  • Michael AngaranoSam Amirante
  • Chris SullivanLead Prosecutor Bill Kunkle
  • Marin IrelandElizabeth Piest
  • Greg BrykHarold Piest
  • Etienne KelliciSamuel Stapleton
  • Finlay Wojtak-HissongRandy Reffett
  • Ted DykstraDet. Allen Fanholm
  • Cricket BrownKerry Piest
  • Nina KiriMary Amirante
  • Chloe AvakianPatti Szyc
  • Mary WisemanKaren Gacy
  • Kristine NielsenMarion Gacy
  • Sprague GraydenBessie Stapleton
  • Lena PepeJuanita
  • Krista BridgesRosemarie Szyc
  • Christian BakoMarko Butkovich
  • Dan LettDr. Stein

 

  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   
  •   

Take Plex everywhere

Watch free anytime, anywhere, on almost any device.
See the full list of supported devices
    Watch Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy - Season 1 • Episode 3 - Samuel and Randy Full Episode Online - Plex