Conspiracy theory enthusiast Ryan deep-dives into mysteries surrounding notorious unsolved crimes, in order to convince his dubious friend Shane that, sometimes, the evidence isn't always as it seems.
The Unusual Australian Shark Arm MurdersA shark, a speedboat and a mysterious severed arm
The Suspicious Case of the Reykjavik Confessions
E3
The Suspicious Case of the Reykjavik ConfessionsTwo murders. Six confessions. But is any of it real?
The Unexplained Murder Of Mobster Bugsy Siegel
E4
The Unexplained Murder Of Mobster Bugsy SiegelWho bumped off the man who built Las Vegas?
The Horrifying Texarkana Phantom Killer
E5
The Horrifying Texarkana Phantom KillerA shadowy killer pushes a small town to the edge.
The Shocking Florida Machete Murder
E6
The Shocking Florida Machete MurderViolence terrorizes a quiet Florida community.
The Puzzling Disappearance Of Walter Collins
E7
The Puzzling Disappearance Of Walter CollinsWhat became of this missing boy?
The Curious Death Of Vincent Van Gogh
E8
The Curious Death Of Vincent Van GoghDo we really know the life and death of this famous artist?
The Impossible Disappearance Of Dorothy Arnold
E9
The Impossible Disappearance Of Dorothy ArnoldA 25-year-old socialite goes missing off the streets of New York City in 1910. Did she run away…or was it something worse?
Cast of Season 5
Shane MadejSelf - Host / Producer
Ryan BergaraSelf - Host / Producer
Katie LeBlancProducer
Take Plex everywhere
Watch free anytime, anywhere, on almost any device.
