As told by Rob Schrab and Dan Harmon on the legendary Harmontown Podcast, they were going to be with producers for a pitch meeting,, at the last second Schrab just said the words, "monster...house" as a throw-away idea.
And despite the 10 other developed pitches, the producers were only interested in Monster House.
THEN, Harmon and Schrab had to reverse engineer the plot and figure out: how the heck does a house become a monster?
Overall, I think they did pretty well despite the obvious problems with some of the plot holes.
There are some particular things about the movie that are completely Dan Harmon, and Harmon's deep fans will know them when they see them. For example, just as everyone knows Quinton has a thing for feet, Harmon has a thing for redheads.
One can also infer a lot of DNA that would end up in Harmon's Community. Dan Harmon spoke a lot about how each of the seven community characters represented a piece of his own personality split up into these essential, yet broken characters. You can see that same thing happening with these characters, but on a smaller scale. The two boys represent one who is self-conscious and intelligent and the other who is comfortable in their own skin yet reckless and awkward in the world. Both of them are oddities to the smart cute girl in their neighborhood from a different part of town who is strategically targeting the area for sales. Anyway.... The point is if you pay attention, you can see something personality traits in each of the three main characters, including the five supporting characters, that would be features of the characters in Community.
Ultimately Rob and Dan only get story credit, so I wonder what their version of the script was like before it was rewritten and credit given to a third person. I don't know the story behind that, so I wonder how much the harmonian/schrabian signature humor was in the original version.