Jerry SpringerSelf - Host Greg BrownStrip club patron Rene Michelle ArandaBracamontes Jeff HoukalDetective Brown Dave BeaudrieDetective Glazer Edgar NentwigDetective Rick Morton Anne McDanielsNatalya Bartender & Pole Dancer John ZacchinoDetective Tony Matthews Marc AbbinkDetective Partner David GhilardiDetective Trombly Chad Bishop'English' Dave Amos Janelle MarieBonita Money Adrienne ArnoSelf - criminal psychologist Nick StellateDetective Reid Richard Maximus Fleming-VlamingenDr. Brennan Johnny AlexanderDetective Vincent Houpe Gary PrivateLuis Hidalgo - (Mr. H.) Tom LazarDetective Joseph Alison WhitneyJodi Barrus Jordan Michael GreenAlex Kinyua Chanel MinnifieldApril Kinyua Jonathan ChironnaCharles Stuart Tom McLarenDr. Howard Appledorf Anthony RutowiczBiker Boyfriend Jackie Di CrystalSuzanne Alguelles Christie NichollsSusan White Josh CanfieldNY Times Reporter David Dunlap Jeffrey Scott BashamHoodlum #1 Max LandwirthShaun Murphy David CoxSelf - Jerrod Kinuya Amir AbdullahGregory Jenkins Michelle OrtizDiana Tamayo Jodi FleisherDetective Jodi Matthew CampbellBrian Austin Green Melissa JohnstonEmily Sander Aidan BristowGary McKenna Justin NesbittJeffrey Soiu Eric BrennerMale Cop Clerk Daphnique SpringsRuby Livingston Vic StaglianoRuss Sander-Emily's Father Alyssa Gabrielle RodriguezStephanie Gary Anthony StennetteHoward Wilson Tara-Nicole AzarianJackie's Sister Christopher WarnerDetective Lisagaye TomlinsonHalima Jones Antoinette Mia PettisPaula Cummings Mell BowserAlexander Carter Mark SchaeferDetective Sam Baity Ivy MillerShannen Doherty Darius Devontaye GreenXavier Parks Brendan McCayOfficer Bumbera Nicholas NeveYoung Colton's Friend Michael FelixCharles Hardeman J.D. BrownDetective Weaver Tony CicchettiBank Manager Sky YoungColton Harris-Moore Philip PritchardDet. Raymond Davis Kenny ApelSteven 'Bear' Sirridge Sasha AilieAudrina Patridge Carl WattsCSI Investigator Natalia FerreiroDiane Pellati Alynxia AmericaMiranda dixon Tim McCordLachlan Buchanan James RadcliffeRabbi Fred Neulander Mark BenjaminOfficer Alex Cristina Mendoza LopezAnabel Espindola Alexa ShackelfordYoung Carol Taylor CaldwellShane Kennedy Dylan BusseTammy Sanders Emily Sander's Stepmother Elaine KratofilLora Thomas Frankie O'SullivanDet. Ken Justin GilbertDet. Michael Hecht Emma-Jayne AppleyardTiffany Kristofer SundquistHarold Jason ArmbrusterCharles Hackett John PaolucciNYPD Detective Sgt Larry Wang ParrishTao Tseng - Esmie's Father Natalie PellegriniRebecca Spoon AlexanderLewis Money Holly StinnettBank Teller Robert RenderosOfficer Garitta Tara PhillipsPalamino Pole Dancer Steven LamprinosOfficer Ben Lisa ArnettBurt Pugach's Mistress Marshall DuncanLewis Joyner Jeff Marc GrossmanSub Shop Guy Elain RinehartSynagogue Woman Michael Anthony DiNuzzoBartender Masen FaisonLatasha Nichols Dustin SisneyDetective Hale Anthony DeArceFreddie Mack Damian DesireeCharles Dingle Rebecca FuocoParis Hilton Melissa NassauerAnne (16yrs) Kelly PhelanElla Mae Cooley Scott McRaeDeputy Spruell Kevin CaliberPolice Officer Randy Jay BurrellKent McGowen Andre AnthonyMichael Schaeffer Brian GilleeceGerry D'Elia Ashley WolffChad's Daughter Nick LavelleMario Jimenez Jero MedinaDetective Martinez Andrea AndersonLisa Hickman Brittany BellandJennifer Cave Justin J BaradSpade Cooley Emily KillianMichelle Harrison Zach Paul BrownCole Reynolds Kimberly SpakBeverly Pinder Julyza CommodoreYoung Doris Payne Monique FilipsPauline martinez Danny HansenBud Davenport Caroline RedekoppDetective O'Brian Daniel NemesJosh Hanshaft Heath CentazzoDetective Frank Milanesi Laura Elizabeth HallWoman Daniel V. GraulauDeputy Ramirez Blake Alec MirandaFred Martinez Marcus NatividadDrug Lord David RobertsonCinematographer Julia Van VlietCostume Designer Nancy WeiCostume Designer Smith GloverPost Producer Dana MeltonAssociate Story Producer Travis FieldsStory Producer Genevieve WongStory Producer 
