One Tree HillI Love You But I've Chosen Darkness

Directed by Stuart Gillard
TV-14
S4 • E5    Oct 25, 2006    42m
8.68.3
Watch on Disney+
On Disney+
Sponsored
Nathan gets two surprises in a row, and everyone is eager to share their advice with him. Deb also shares something she picked up. Brooke decides to celebrate while Peyton is being attacked by her stalker.
  • Chad Michael MurrayLucas Scott
  • James LaffertyNathan Scott
  • Bethany Joy LenzHaley James Scott
  • Sophia BushBrooke Davis
  • Hilarie Burton MorganPeyton Sawyer
  • Lee NorrisMarvin 'Mouth' McFadden
  • Barry CorbinWhitey Durham
  • Moira KellyKaren Roe
  • Paul JohanssonDan Scott
  • Danneel AcklesRachel Gatina
  • Barbara Alyn WoodsDeb Scott
  • Antwon TannerAntwon 'Skills' Taylor
  • Ernest WaddellDerek Sommers
  • Matt BarrDerek
  • Rey ValentinNick Chavez
  • Brett RiceDetective
  • Shawn ShepardPrincipal Turner
  • Cari MoskowGirl
  • Ashleigh FallsNurse
  • Michael BurgessOfficer

Get Plex on Your Devices

Free on 20+ platforms. Pick yours.
See all supported devices →