Jeremiah LongBasketball Player Jeff WeekleyClayton Whittemore's Dad Angeline HartmannSelf - Crime Analyst Bob YarbroughSelf - Reporter Victoria AtkinJenelle Potter Christian JamesMike Bargo Danny FehsenfeldDetective Park Ben VanderMeyClayton Whittemore Joanne RyanDetective Rice Nicholas ZarrilloIsreal Nieves Maia OsmanBrittany Jenkins Nick ApostolidesEdward Richardson Chelle RamosDetective Rivera Larry HerringCampus Police Officer Jennifer ScibettaNona's Mom Corey LandisDetective Barnes Mike StanleyDetective Kravitz Keith BrooksChris Dannevig William TokarskyMelvin Potter Ariel EliazDetective Nivens Lacy HartselleHayley Jones Mia TopalianSarah Ludemann Keller FornesSeath Jackson Sarah StuntNona Belomesoff Tyler BuckinghamJason Green Tasos HernandezJason Rodriguez Tiffan BorelliDetective Moreland Michael JacquesDetective Hill James Arthur WilliamsExtra (Forensic Investigator) Nicholas HaynerChris Wright Stephen William TennerDetective Sykes Christopher PrchalMatthew Puccio Thiree PinnockHank Burnett Sherod OgletreeRon's Brother Tom MorrisSelf - Crime Reporter Tracy WalkerCIA Secretary Alexandra TebanoRachel Wade Laura SchoonmakerSharon Cook Midwin CharlesSelf - Legal Analyst Michael P. WalkerThe Hooded Murderer Victoria GalenSusan Jones Eric GusterSelf - Legal Analyst Leigh ScarbroughTrain station extra Stefan GutmanOfficer at PD Ginger TolarHigh School Student Robbie PaskiewiczExtra (Detective) Shelia WoffordRonald's Grandmother Jacole ChandlerBest friend Te'Andre MooreJosh's Friend Jaden Lily BransonNewspaper girl Tyler GregoryAndrew Forney Steven PeglowSelf - Monroe County Sheriff's Investigator Jessica HeffnerSelf - Former Newscenter 7 Reporter Caitlin ElledgeSelf - Legal Analyst Meaghan McDermottSelf - Reporter for Democrat and Chronicle David GrossSchrijver / Story Producer Judd TrichterContributing Writer Deborah AllenExecutive Producer Stephen LandExecutive Producer Allison WallachExecutive Producer Jacob CoffinAssociate Producer Natasha HortonAssociate Producer Katie SimpsonAssociate Producer Alexander SablowCinematographer Eric WetheringtonSupervising Producer Alexis LinkletterField Producer Brittany WoodardSeries Producer 
