Josh LucasMatthew Wakefield James Van Der BeekDiploma / Roggiani Jessica ChastainSally Ann Morena BaccarinRose Montgomery Andy MilderWilliam Daniels Jude CiccolellaPolice Chief Graham PhillipsMark Wakefield Sam HenningsOlder Luke Wakefield Tom KempRussell MacArthur Benjamin BurdickGeorge Montgomery Bob StephensonMike the Bartender William Charles MitchellLou Glenn TarantoChollie / Schrijver Enuka OkumaOfficer Angie Riddick Cheyenne WilburOld Minister Pamela DunlapShelly the Waitress Rutanya AldaOlder Sally Ann James MathersJoel Schubert Jonathan Erickson EisleyMick Charles C. Stevenson Jr.Man Getting a Cut Bart McCarthyKevin Byrnes Beresford BennettInvestigator Glenn TarantoChollie / Schrijver Jennifer SpenceProduction Design Thomas SpenceArt Direction Andy SteinmanDirector Of Photography Lisa NorciaCostume Design Trevor MorrisOriginal Music Composer Stephanie CorsaliniCasting Richie WolfeProduction Supervisor 
