Lady in the Water
Directed by M. Night ShyamalanApartment building superintendent Cleveland Heep rescues what he thinks is a young woman from the pool he maintains. When he discovers that she is actually a character from a bedtime story who is trying to make the journey back to her home, he works with his tenants to protect his new friend from the creatures that are determined to keep her in our world.
Lady in the Water Ratings & Reviews
- sopulaJanuary 17, 2026"fuq u" -m night
- aamillikinOctober 28, 2025Laughably bad.
- ShaydeknightOctober 27, 2025I really wanted to like Lady in the Water. On paper, it's a modern fairy tale in the spirit of the Brothers Grimm or Hans Christian Andersen: intimate, old-school folklore. It should have been a perfect playground for Shyamalan's sense of mystery and atmosphere. Unfortunately, what emerges is a film that depends far too heavily on verbal exposition rather than through visual storytelling or emotional discovery. The premise is intriguing: a superintendent named Cleveland Heep (Paul Giamatti) discovers a mysterious young woman (Bryce Dallas Howard) living in the pool of his apartment complex, who turns out to be a "Narf", a kind of sea nymph sent to inspire a writer destined to change the world. The problem isn't the concept, which is charming at its core, but rather the way Shyamalan chooses to deliver it. Instead of inviting us into a dreamlike world of discovery, he has characters stop the story cold to explain the mythology, piece by piece, as if reading footnotes aloud. It's the cinematic equivalent of overhearing someone at a cocktail party explain a story to another person while you stand awkwardly nearby. Paul Giamatti gives the film its emotional weight (I think he's one of the best actors working) and his ability to convey deep pain with just a glance does a lot of heavy lifting here. His character's backstory is genuinely tragic, but it's discovered in the clumsiest way imaginable and comes out in the story in the most absurd, ill-timed manner, robbing the moment of its potential power. Bryce Dallas Howard, meanwhile, seems trapped by the material. She's ethereal, yes, but also emotionally vacant, though that's more a problem of writing than performance. Cinematographer Christopher Doyle (known for his luminous work with Wong Kar-wai) brings a beautiful, humid glow to the film. The water sparkles, the night scenes breathe, and the apartment complex itself feels and enchanted. James Newton Howard's score, as usual, is lush and deeply felt, almost too beautiful for the story it's attached to. These technical elements suggest a better movie waiting to be born. What Lady in the Water wants to be is a fable about community and faith, about the way ordinary people are desperate to rediscover wonder and are willing to come together around something magical. What it ends up being, however, is a strangely self-regarding work, a film more interested in celebrating its own mythology (and, by extension, its creator) than in making us believe in it. Shyamalan even casts himself as the writer whose words will change the world, which tips the film from sincerity into vanity. There are moments that still work: the quiet tenderness between Cleveland and the Narf, the idea that each tenant has an unrecognized role to play in a larger story. But the film is too saccharine, too schematic, and too dependent on play-by-play narration to ever fully come alive. Worse, it's full of scenes that could be resolved instantly if the characters would just speak plainly to one another. I wanted to like it the way I love The Fall, City of Lost Children, or even Hugo, films that mix fantasy and melancholy with grace. But Lady in the Water feels like Shyamalan recounting his kids' bedtime stories and then refusing to let the rest of us drift into the dream. It's a beautiful idea trapped in an awkward telling, a fairy tale that tells us about magic but never really makes any.
- Gianni CavuotoOctober 22, 2025This is a movie that requires some buy-in. If you have a level of buy-in you will get it, if not I don't think you will understand or like this movie. When it comes to M. Night Shyamalan movies I will have already bought in prior to even knowing the plot. I'm a believer in his craft. This one is a bit fantastical, not that others aren't but this movie really goes out there, and I believe it and appreciate all of the hard work that went into this movie. It may not be his best work but it still a GREAT movie. Not every movie can be Unbreakable or The Sixth Sense. Watch it, you wont regret it.
- Alexander SierputowskiJuly 29, 2025This is a great comedy fantasy drama!
- Daniel GustavssonOctober 11, 2024A funny thing here is that I actually saw this in the cinema. To be honest I was busy doing other things at that time, and I always had the impression that this movie was passable. Now, many years later, I wanted to watch it again since I didn't remember anything from it at all. And wow. What can I say? It's unbelievable that this abomination ever got sent to cinemas! When the movie ended I was literally questioning how that could have been possible. To say the least, it's one of the worst movies ever made, and to some extent it seemed to had been almost created intentionally awful. How else do you explain the acting from Paul Giamatti, which is by leaps and bounds one of the worst acting performances I have ever seen. Many of the support cast is bad too, but nothing compares to the lead role here. And the plot, I don't even know where to begin, it is simply atrocious. And boring. And completely nonsensical. And the directing is a trainwreck - it really seemed as if many shots are done awfully on purpose here too because how else would you explain it? But why would anyone do such a thing to his own movie? For some laughs maybe? Let me tell you, this movie is so bad that it's not even laughable, and I am not kidding. Nothing is funny here and it even started to get on my nerves towards the end. It's also a complete joke how the movie does some of the most pathetic attempts I have ever seen at being clever. Like having a character talking about how people usually die in a horror movie and how cliche this and that is, and then the movie actually breaks the pattern, and if that wasn't pathetic enough, the way it does so is by the most PG friendly way I have ever seen, making the joke fall so flat that I am at a loss for words. And I guess the ending is supposed to be a joke? Right? Like the rest of the movie then? I have no idea honestly, but it misfires with such a huge margin that it doesn't matter anyway. I have no idea what Shyamalan was doing here but he should be ashamed over each and every aspect of this movie. There are many movies that I don't like, but this and "Lights Out" are the only 2 movies I have ever wondered how they could be passed to cinemas. It's just so many levels down from what anyone could call a passable movie for any audience whatsoever. If you haven't got the hint yet, you shouldn't see this movie.
Watch Lady in the Water Videos
Lady in the Water Trivia
Lady in the Water was released on July 19, 2006.
Lady in the Water was directed by M. Night Shyamalan.
Lady in the Water has a runtime of 1h 49m.
Lady in the Water was produced by Sam Mercer, M. Night Shyamalan.
Apartment building superintendent Cleveland Heep rescues what he thinks is a young woman from the pool he maintains. When he discovers that she is actually a character from a bedtime story who is trying to make the journey back to her home, he works with his tenants to protect his new friend from the creatures that are determined to keep her in our world.
The key characters in Lady in the Water are Cleveland Heep (Paul Giamatti), Story (Bryce Dallas Howard), Mr. Dury (Jeffrey Wright).
Lady in the Water is rated PG-13.
Lady in the Water is a Drama, Thriller, Fantasy film.
Lady in the Water has an audience rating of 4.9 out of 10.
Lady in the Water had a budget of $70M.
Lady in the Water has made $72.8M at the box office.