M. Emmet WalshChuck Ireland Scott AaronsonBaseball Coach Nicholas BradyYoung Roger Andrew BryniarskiGang Member Ricardo ChaviraDr. Boogie Mercedes ConnorAdmittance Nurse Cris D'AnnunzioPrincipal Motley / Screenplay Kevin GageShort Order Cook Michael GoviaThe Minister Ryan R. JohnsonER Doctor / Producer Madison LaneseyMaddy Straka Meritt LatimorePirates Fan Louis LombardiShort Order Cook Zander LyonsYoung Baseball Player Christopher MayCoach Johnson Michael O'KeefeDr. Stuart Katie PielJr. Nurse K. Copland Alisa SchulzSally the Waitress Patrick SebesBobby Straka Geoffrey GouldER Doctor (uncredited) Bill MikitaFirst Base Coach (uncredited) / Producer / Story David MorsePirates Fan (uncredited) Greg LaneseyDirector / Screenplay Cris D'AnnunzioPrincipal Motley / Screenplay Ryan R. JohnsonER Doctor / Producer Patrick GallagherExecutive Producer Bill MikitaFirst Base Coach (uncredited) / Producer / Story Kenn CoplanProduction Design Rose ShawhanSet Decoration Michael BarakatArt Direction Matt HausmannArt Direction Denis MaloneyDirector Of Photography Marianne ParkerCostume Design Kathy McHughScript Supervisor Lawrence ShraggeOriginal Music Composer Sean FernaldMusic Supervisor Michael O. GallantLine Producer Daniel BenedictUnit Production Manager Cory CopeUnit Production Manager Lynn M. van KuilenburgLocation Manager Larry FojtikProduction Coordinator