The true story of suburban housewife Gertrude Baniszewski, who kept a teenage girl locked in the basement of her Indiana home during the 1960s.
Directed By
Tommy O'HaverWritten By
Tommy O'Haver, Irene TurnerStudio
First Look International, Killer Films, Showtime NetworksCast of An American Crime
Elliot PageSylvia Likens
Catherine KeenerGertrude Baniszewski
Hayley McFarlandJennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens
Nick SearcyLester Likens
Romy RosemontBetty Likens
Ari GraynorPaula Baniszewski
Scout Taylor-ComptonStephanie Baniszewski
Tristan JarredJohnny Baniszewski
Hannah LeighShirley Baniszewski
Bradley WhitfordProsecutor
James FrancoAndy
Scott EastwoodEric
Michael O'KeefeReverend Bill Collier
Carlie WestermanMarie Baniszewski
Michelle BenesHope Orbach
Jeremy SumpterCoy Hubbard
Brian GeraghtyBradley
Channing NicholsPatty
Michael WelchTeddy
Evan PetersRicky Hobbs
Amy FergusonSally
Will CarterOfficer Waters
Edward James GageBailiff
Patricia PlaceMrs. Doyle
Paul GraceCottin Candy Vendor (uncredited)
James MeehanDefense Attorney (uncredited)
Paul PaloNewspaper Reporter (uncredited)
Gary SieversCarnie (uncredited)