The story behind Sylvester Stallone starring in Rocky is almost as compelling as Rocky itself, and I Play Rocky shows just how unlikely his success really was. Instead of looking back at 1970s Hollywood through a rosy lens, Peter Farrelly focuses on the money troubles, constant rejection, and uncertainty Stallone faced as he took a chance on his script. The cramped apartments and dreary studio offices feel a long way from the Hollywood success story we know today. Farrelly doesn't shy away from the humiliating moments, especially the meetings with executives who can barely picture an unknown nobody with a dream in the lead role. But this just means that when things come around, Stallone's breakthroughs are all the more satisfying.
Anthony Ippolito, a young up-and-coming actor himself, is terrific as Stallone. He captures both his stubborn pride and his vulnerability without turning him into any kind of caricature. You can feel how much this means to him, especially as his confidence starts to give way to desperation. Stephan James is a welcome presence as Carl Weathers, and the supporting cast brings plenty of energy to the studio conflicts. The final stretch does slip into familiar showbiz territory, particularly as production becomes a race against time and money. That's a small complaint, though. Overall, I Play Rocky stands as an inspiring reminder of what can happen when someone refuses to let other people decide what they're capable of.