The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
Des morts suspectes dans les environs de Seattle laissent présager une nouvelle menace pour Bella. Victoria cherche toujours à assouvir sa vengeance contre elle et rassemble une armée. Malgré leur haine ancestrale, les Cullen et les Quileutes vont devoir faire une trêve et s'associer pour avoir une chance de la sauver. Mais Bella est obligée de choisir entre son amour pour Edward et son amitié pour Jacob tout en sachant que sa décision risque de relancer la guerre entre les deux clans. Alors que l'armée de Victoria approche, Bella est confrontée à la plus importante décision de sa vie.
Hakihiko a rédigé une critique
8 mars 2025•
Still Lacking Depth
"Twilight Saga: Eclipse" brings more action and higher stakes to the series, making it a slight improvement over New Moon. However, while it refines some aspects of the franchise, it still suffers from weak dialogue, an unconvincing love triangle, and inconsistent pacing.
Kristen Stewart's Bella remains emotionally detached, making it difficult to connect with her struggles. Robert Pattinson's Edward and Taylor Lautner's Jacob both get more screen time, but their rivalry feels repetitive and forced rather than compelling. Lautner brings more energy to his role, but the chemistry between the three leads still feels unbalanced. The supporting cast, including the Cullens and the Volturi, continues to be underdeveloped, despite having the potential to add more intrigue to the story.
The film does benefit from improved action sequences, especially the final battle, which offers some well-executed choreography and visual effects. The werewolves are more involved this time, adding a new dynamic to the story. The cinematography also moves away from the overly muted color tones of the first two films, giving "Eclipse" a slightly fresher look.
Despite these improvements, "Eclipse" still struggles with clunky dialogue, uneven storytelling, and a romance that lacks emotional depth. While it provides some entertainment value, especially in its action moments, it fails to fully deliver on its potential.
Hakihiko a rédigé une critique
8 mars 2025•
Still Lacking Depth
"Twilight Saga: Eclipse" brings more action and higher stakes to the series, making it a slight improvement over New Moon. However, while it refines some aspects of the franchise, it still suffers from weak dialogue, an unconvincing love triangle, and inconsistent pacing.
Kristen Stewart's Bella remains emotionally detached, making it difficult to connect with her struggles. Robert Pattinson's Edward and Taylor Lautner's Jacob both get more screen time, but their rivalry feels repetitive and forced rather than compelling. Lautner brings more energy to his role, but the chemistry between the three leads still feels unbalanced. The supporting cast, including the Cullens and the Volturi, continues to be underdeveloped, despite having the potential to add more intrigue to the story.
The film does benefit from improved action sequences, especially the final battle, which offers some well-executed choreography and visual effects. The werewolves are more involved this time, adding a new dynamic to the story. The cinematography also moves away from the overly muted color tones of the first two films, giving "Eclipse" a slightly fresher look.
Despite these improvements, "Eclipse" still struggles with clunky dialogue, uneven storytelling, and a romance that lacks emotional depth. While it provides some entertainment value, especially in its action moments, it fails to fully deliver on its potential.
